Disability Insurance: The Cost of Being Female
October 18, 2009
Categories
Financial Planning, Insurance, Residents & Interns
Although actuarially women are better risks for life insurance compared to men, it is the opposite for disability insurance. As a result, women may pay 50% to 75% more for their policies.
However, many disability insurance carriers offer a “multi-life” discount when several physicians from the same hospital or department purchase individual policies at the same time and a letter of endorsement is submitted by the program director, GME department or human resource director. While these programs can produce a savings for males, this strategy allows female physicians to save up to 60% on the cost of their disability insurance.
It is important to note that many teaching hospitals and medical associations have existing programs that you can access – without having to take the time and effort to establish them. You should make sure to ask the insurance agent or financial planner you are dealing with about the availability of these programs or look for one that specializes in working with physicians as they most likely have access to several of them.
Look at the Savings Using a Multi-Life or Association Discount
Multi-Life Discount
Dr. Jones, a 30-year old female Orthopaedic Surgery Resident in New York, purchased her policy from a well-known insurance company. Assuming a monthly benefit of $3,500, a 90-day waiting period, benefits payable to age 65, a Residual Disability Rider and a 3% Cost Of Living Adjustment Rider, her fixed annual premium would be $3,055. However, that same policy with a unisex rate and “multi-life” discount would cost $2,056… an annual savings of $999 or approximately 33% off of the normal female rates. If she kept her policy at the same level to age 65, she would save approximately $35,000. If she invested her annual savings at 6% for the 35-year period, her savings would grow to be in excess of $118,000!
Medical Association Discount
Dr. Smith, a 30-year old female Anesthesiology Resident in Massachusetts, purchased her policy from another well-known insurance company. Assuming a monthly benefit of $3,500, a 90-day waiting period, benefits payable to age 67, a Non-Ccancellable Rider, an “Own-Occupation” Rider, a Residual Disability Rider and a 3% Cost Of Living Adjustment Rider, her fixed annual premium would be $3,300. However, that same policy with an association discount would cost $1,426… an annual savings of $1,874 or approximately 57% off of the normal female rates. If she kept her policy at the same level to age 67, she would save approximately $69,000. If she invested her annual savings at 6% for the 37-year period, her savings would grow to be in excess $252,000!
Watch Out for Florida and California
It is not unreasonable to think that most physicians would rather be on the beach then in their offices. Therefore, claims experience has been extremely poor in these states. As a result, policies are typically 10%-20% more expensive with less liberal contract provisions. As a result, if you are not in Florida or California now, but plan on moving or returning to either one of these states after you complete your training, you should purchase you policy before you get there. You will be able to lock into lower premium rates for your initial coverage as well as any future additions that you make to your policy.